Knowledge

Preservatives and the Challenge Test: How a Cosmetic Is Kept Clean

A cream, a shower gel and a shampoo all contain water, and water invites microbial growth. Cosmetic products can be exposed to microbial contamination during storage or transport, and manufacturers add preservative compounds to protect the product from spoilage [7]. The preservative system is therefore not a minor line on the formula sheet. It is the part of the product that decides whether what the consumer opens in month eight is the same thing that left the filling line.

The way that decision is proven is the challenge test. It is a procedure that evaluates preservative efficacy by challenging the product with test microorganisms, to determine the quality of preservation [7]. The product is deliberately inoculated, then counted at intervals. Nothing about the ingredient list tells you this on its own — the test is done on the finished formula, in its finished state.

What a challenge test actually shows

Those uncontaminated samples were then assessed against European Pharmacopeia 7.0 standards [7].

The results are a useful picture of what passing and failing look like. Two samples — a foaming gel and a body and face cream — failed to demonstrate the required microbiocidal effect against the S. aureus test species, recording 1.21 x 105 and 6.80 x 105 CFU/ml respectively at the second day of incubation [7]. The other products — shower gel, hand wash, body lotion and shampoo — demonstrated the required effect against the test species at day 2, day 7, day 14 and through to day 28, with microbial counts below 10 across all incubation periods [7]. The study's conclusion for manufacturers was direct: add a good preservative system and examine products before sale [7].

Two things are worth noticing. Second, the same preservative approach can succeed in one base and fail in another. A gel and a cream are different environments.

Why formulators keep looking for alternatives

Pressure on conventional preservatives is real and documented. A review in Contact Dermatitis examined EU legislation on classification and labelling, biocides and cosmetics for the most used sensitizing preservatives, including formaldehyde-releasing substances, isothiazolinones and parabens [1]. The authors note that the widespread use of skin sensitizing preservatives is well known, and that contact allergy to preservatives is often caused by their presence in cosmetic products [1]. Analysing the Swedish Products Register from 1995 to 2018, they found that several use concentrations had declined following harmonized classification as a skin sensitizer with low concentration limits [1].

Exposure to these ingredients has also been modelled against real measurements. A study in the Journal of Exposure Science & Environmental Epidemiology compared five exposure models with urinary excretion data from eight individuals for triclosan and methyl-, ethyl- and n-propyl- parabens [4]. Roughly 60–90% of model predictions fell within a factor of 10 of observed exposures, and about 30–40% within a factor of 3 [4]. The authors flagged uncertainties in preservative product concentrations and dermal absorption parameters as influences on interpretation [4]. For a brand, the practical reading is that the amount of preservative in a product, and how consistently it is there, is information that matters beyond the factory.

Work on alternatives names the motive plainly. A 2022 paper in the International Journal of Molecular Sciences opens by saying that controversy over certain preservatives makes it necessary to seek new ecological alternatives free of adverse effects on users [3].

Four routes that have been tested

Multifunctional ingredient blends. A 2024 study in Scientific Reports identified five multifunctional ingredients with antimicrobial properties — sodium coco PG-dimonium chloride phosphate, ricinoleic acid, palmitoleic acid, raspberry ketone and sorbitan caprylate — and prepared 150 combinations to find synergies [8]. Three synergistic compositions emerged, at ratios of 1:6.3:6.3 and 1:6.3:15.7 for the first three ingredients, and 1:12.5:37.5 for sodium coco PG-dimonium chloride phosphate with palmitoleic acid and sorbitan caprylate [8]. These combinations showed lower Minimum Inhibitory Concentration values than their individual components, and all three successfully preserved a colour protection shampoo, a body wash shower gel and a skin-lightening cream for up to 28 days in a preservation challenge test [8].

Encapsulated natural terpenes. The natural terpene thymoquinone was encapsulated in chitosan nanoparticles around 20 nm in size, which gave stabilization and sustained release [3]. Antimicrobial activity was tested against typical microbial contaminants found in cosmetic products, and a natural moisturizing cream was formulated with the nanoparticles and inoculated with those microorganisms to evaluate preservative efficiency [3].

Plant-derived silver particles. Biogenic silver nanoparticles were obtained from Iris tuberosa leaf extract via green chemistry and characterised by UV-vis spectroscopy and dynamic light scattering; transmission electron microscopy showed spheric and irregular particles 5 to 50 nm in diameter [2]. They were tested against typical cosmetic contaminants and then put into a natural moisturizing cream for a challenge test [2].

Zinc oxide particles. Unirradiated and γ-irradiated zinc oxide nanoparticles were compared with commonly used preservatives by challenge test across six different preparation types [5]. They passed the challenge test in all types tested, and were reported as superior to the comparator preservatives in all tested preparations [5]. Gamma irradiation enhanced antimicrobial activity and reduced particle size in proportion to the applied dose, and during storage the particles kept microbial counts within the acceptable range [5]. The authors also reported compatibility with the components of all tested products [5].

The preservative changes the formula around it

A preservative is never neutral to the rest of the product. Ethanol is a multifunctional excipient often used as a preservative in topical formulations [6]. A 2025 study in Pharmaceutics put fluorescent dyes into creams with and without ethanol as surrogates for active ingredients, and measured penetration on an ex vivo porcine ear model [6]. Ethanol reduced penetration by about 40% for the hydrophilic surrogate and about 20% for the lipophilic one on intact skin [6]. It also altered bio-physical properties, increasing transepidermal water loss and decreasing hydration on intact skin [6]. The authors concluded that ethanol use needs careful consideration, balancing preservative benefit against potential to impair the efficacy of active ingredients [6].

What a brand should take from this

Choose the preservative system with the base, not after it. Ask for the challenge test on your actual formula, in its actual pack, with counts reported at day 2, 7, 14 and 28 rather than a single end-point [7][8]. And check what the preservative does to everything else: compatibility with the other components was reported as part of the zinc oxide assessment [5], while ethanol measurably changed how much of a model active reached the skin [6].

References

  1. Lidén C, Andersson N, White IR. Preservatives in non-cosmetic products: Increasing human exposure requires action for protection of health — Contact dermatitis, 2022-07-18.
  2. Mondéjar-López M, López-Jiménez AJ, Abad-Jordá M, Rubio-Moraga A, Ahrazem O, Gómez-Gómez L, Niza E. Biogenic Silver Nanoparticles from Iris tuberosa as Potential Preservative in Cosmetic Products — Molecules (Basel, Switzerland), 2021-08-03.
  3. Mondéjar-López M, López-Jiménez AJ, Martínez JCG, Ahrazem O, Gómez-Gómez L, Niza E. Thymoquinone-Loaded Chitosan Nanoparticles as Natural Preservative Agent in Cosmetic Products — International journal of molecular sciences, 2022-01-14.
  4. Aylward L, Vilone G, Cowan-Ellsberry C, Arnot JA, Westgate JN, O'Mahony C, Hays SM. Exposure to selected preservatives in personal care products: case study comparison of exposure models and observational biomonitoring data — Journal of exposure science & environmental epidemiology, 2018-12-05.
  5. Hosny AEM, Kashef MT, Taher HA, El-Bazza ZE. The use of unirradiated and γ-irradiated zinc oxide nanoparticles as a preservative in cosmetic preparations — International journal of nanomedicine, 2017-09-12.
  6. Raab C, Do TT, Keck CM. Influence of Ethanol as a Preservative in Topical Formulation on the Dermal Penetration Efficacy of Active Compounds in Healthy and Barrier-Disrupted Skin — Pharmaceutics, 2025-02-04.
  7. Alshehrei FM. Microbiological Quality Assessment of Skin and Body care Cosmetics by using Challenge test — Saudi journal of biological sciences, 2024-02-28.
  8. Senthilkumar K, Vijayalakshmi A, Jagadeesan M, Somasundaram A, Pitchiah S, Gowri SS, Ali Alharbi S, Javed Ansari M, Ramasamy P. Preparation of self-preserving personal care cosmetic products using multifunctional ingredients and other cosmetic ingredients — Scientific reports, 2024-08-21.

All articles

Tell us what you want to make

Send us the product, the quantity and where you sell it.
Factory visits are welcome.

Contact us