Stability Testing: How a Cosmetic Is Checked for Its Shelf Life
Stability testing is the work of proving that a product leaving the factory will still be the same product months later in a warehouse, a shop or a bathroom. It is not one test. It is a set of measurements repeated over time, on samples held at different temperatures, comparing what the product looks like, how thick it is, what pH it sits at, and how much of its active ingredient is still there.
The published literature on cosmetic formulations shows fairly consistently which measurements are used, and — more usefully for a brand — which formulation decisions decide whether the product passes.
What gets measured
The simplest stability protocol watches physical signs. A study of a formulation containing tannase-converted green tea extract evaluated physical stability by measuring pH, precipitation and colour, at 25 ± 2 °C with ambient humidity and at 40 ± 2 °C with 70 ± 5% relative humidity, over four months [3]. The formulation containing 5% of the extract showed relatively stable pH, precipitation and colour for 16 weeks [3]. Two temperatures, three observations, one long calendar — that is the shape of a basic shelf-life study.
Precipitation here means solid matter dropping out of a liquid or cream that was uniform when it was made. Colour drift and pH drift are the other two things a customer or an inspector can see or check quickly.
A study on grape seed extracts in a cream widened the temperature range and added mechanical stress. Stability of a Marselan hydro-glyceric extract incorporated into a commercial cream was tested at 4, 25 and 50 °C, at four concentrations (5, 4, 3 and 2%), over four months, using centrifugation, heat-shock cycles, pH and viscosity [8]. All the formulations were stable over the whole four months, with the highest stability at 4 °C and the least at 50 °C [8]. That gradient is the point of running more than one temperature: heat is the accelerator, and the hot samples tell you first where a formula will fail.
Centrifugation — spinning a sample hard to force separation — is also used on its own as an early screen. In work on a cosmetic multiple emulsion loaded with 5% Camellia sinensis extract, centrifugation had no devastating effect on physical destabilisation or phase separation over 30 days [6]. The same study measured droplet sizes, finding mean globule sizes of the multiple droplets between 10.29 ± 4.4 μm and 12.77 ± 5.1 μm, and inner droplets between 0.8 ± 0.4 μm and 1.6 ± 0.8 μm [6]. All samples showed shear thinning behaviour as shear stress increased [6]. The authors concluded the system was physically and chemically stable, while noting that long-term stability at elevated temperatures may need suitable modifications [6] — an honest statement of the limit of a 30-day picture.
Flow behaviour counts as stability
How a cream flows is part of what a buyer judges, so it is measured too. A study of a cosmetic formulation containing 1% retinyl palmitate, ascorbyl tetraisopalmitate and tocopheryl acetate used a rheometer to determine the rheological behaviour of the formulations [5]. They showed pseudoplastic behaviour, and the vitamins did not alter their apparent viscosity or thixotropy [5]. Pseudoplastic means the product thins when it is sheared — stirred, pumped, rubbed — and recovers afterwards; thixotropy is how that recovery behaves over time. The finding that adding the actives did not change these properties is itself a stability result: the active did not quietly restructure the base.
Chemical stability: how much is left
Physical tests cannot tell you whether an active has degraded. For that the studies use chromatography. In the vitamin derivative work, chemical stability was determined by HPLC with UV detection, and first-order reaction equations were used to calculate shelf life based on a remaining concentration of 85% [5]. That is the key idea behind a dated shelf life: pick a threshold of remaining active, measure the rate of loss, and compute how long the product stays above it.
The same study found that combining the vitamins in a single formulation gave a slightly lower degradation rate than separate preparations each containing only one of them [5]. The authors suggested the work may contribute to developing more stable formulations containing liposoluble vitamins [5].
HPLC was also the method in a study of verbascoside, obtained from Buddleia davidii meristematic cells through in vitro plant cell culture [1]. Those stability studies showed that an acyl derivative with a less hydrophilic profile was more stable in lipophilic vehicles, while the parent verbascoside was more stable in an oil-in-water emulsion [1]. The lesson generalises: the same active can pass or fail depending on whether the base it sits in is mostly oil or mostly water.
pH and encapsulation as stability tools
Two formulation levers show up repeatedly. The first is pH. Work on ferulic acid in a topical hydrogel compared Gel A, with pH higher than the pKa of ferulic acid, against Gel B, with pH lower [2]. Colour stability of the gel and chemical stability of the ferulic acid were very good in Gel B and poor in Gel A, although Gel A was still significantly better than a gel with unencapsulated ferulic acid [2].
The second lever is encapsulation — wrapping the active in a particle so it is not exposed to the rest of the formula. In that same study, ferulic acid was loaded into nanocapsules made by high pressure homogenisation, with a mean particle size below 300 nm; DSC and XRD indicated the ferulic acid was completely dissolved in the lipid matrix and remained amorphous, and cross-polarised microscopy of the gels showed no un-encapsulated or undissolved crystals [2]. Crystal growth in a finished gel is a visible defect, so that microscopy check is a stability test in its own right.
A separate study quantified what encapsulation bought. Chitosan alginate nanoparticles built by ionotropic pre-gelation followed by polyelectrolyte complexation, with particle size 309 ± 0 nm, PDI 0.39 ± 0.01 and zeta potential −26.0 ± 0.9 mV, raised the proportion of ingredient remaining after three months' storage from 44 ± 5% in solution to 74 ± 4% [7].
What a brand can take from this
References
- Vertuani S, Beghelli E, Scalambra E, Malisardi G, Copetti S, Dal Toso R, Baldisserotto A, Manfredini S. Activity and stability studies of verbascoside, a novel antioxidant, in dermo-cosmetic and pharmaceutical topical formulations — Molecules (Basel, Switzerland), 2011-08-18.
- Das S, Wong ABH. Stabilization of ferulic acid in topical gel formulation via nanoencapsulation and pH optimization — Scientific reports, 2020-07-23.
- Hong YH, Jung EY, Noh DO, Suh HJ. Physiological effects of formulation containing tannase-converted green tea extract on skin care: physical stability, collagenase, elastase, and tyrosinase activities — Integrative medicine research, 2013-12-14.
- Yamanashi Y, Teramoto M, Morimura N, Hirata S, Suzuki J, Hayashi M, Kinoshita K, Murayama M, Idani G. Analysis of hair cortisol levels in captive chimpanzees: Effect of various methods on cortisol stability and variability — MethodsX, 2016-01-16.
- Gianeti MD, Gaspar LR, Camargo FB, Campos PM. Benefits of combinations of vitamin A, C and E derivatives in the stability of cosmetic formulations — Molecules (Basel, Switzerland), 2012-02-22.
- Mahmood T, Akhtar N. Stability of a cosmetic multiple emulsion loaded with green tea extract — TheScientificWorldJournal, 2013-08-24.
- Yeerong K, Chantawannakul P, Anuchapreeda S, Juntrapirom S, Kanjanakawinkul W, Müllertz A, Rades T, Chaiyana W. Chitosan Alginate Nanoparticles of Protein Hydrolysate from Acheta domesticus with Enhanced Stability for Skin Delivery — Pharmaceutics, 2024-05-28.
- Salem Y, Rajha HN, Franjieh D, Hoss I, Manca ML, Manconi M, Manconi M, Castangia I, Perra M, Maroun RG, Louka N. Stability and Antioxidant Activity of Hydro-Glyceric Extracts Obtained from Different Grape Seed Varieties Incorporated in Cosmetic Creams — Antioxidants (Basel, Switzerland), 2022-07-10.