How a Cream Emulsion Is Built — and What Keeps Oil and Water Mixed
A cream is two things that do not naturally stay together: oil and water. The job of the formula is to keep them mixed, evenly, for the whole life of the product. Published formulation work on semisolid creams gives a practical picture of how that is done, what sets the texture, and which measurements tell you whether a batch behaves the way the last one did.
Oil in water, water in oil, and water in water
In one published study, an O/W cream base was designed by first measuring how well the chosen ingredient dissolved in various excipients, and the base was then built around that solubility result [5]. That order matters: the structure of the cream followed from where the active material would sit, not the other way round.
The opposite arrangement is also used. A cream formulation has been described in which a concentrated plant leaf extract was held at 3% inside the inner aqueous phase of the cream, with a matching base containing no extract made as a comparison [2]. Placing an ingredient in an inner phase means it is surrounded by the cream rather than simply stirred into it.
Emulsions do not even have to be oil and water. Researchers have reported a two-phase aqueous system made from two incompatible polymers — dextran and polyethylene oxide — forming a stable water-in-water emulsion, stabilised not by a conventional emulsifier but by solid particles made from whey protein [3]. It is a useful reminder that "what keeps it mixed" can be a film of particles as readily as a surfactant.
Two ingredients can decide the whole texture
The team first defined the critical parameters needed to get close to the reference, then narrowed the work down: the percentages of cetyl palmitate and octyldodecanol were identified as the critical variables and selected for optimisation [6].
Eleven different formulations were made and put through physicochemical characterisation and product performance studies, using a two-factor central composite orthogonal design, so the effect of each of the two variables on each response could be estimated and an optimum point found within a design space [6]. The optimised formulation was then analysed side by side with the reference, and the results agreed with the prediction from the chemometric models [6].
The study also sets out a vocabulary worth borrowing. Two creams can share a full ingredient list and still differ in Q3. The authors describe in vitro release and permeation results that were similar for the reference and the generic formulation, and conclude that microstructure properties, product performance and stability are interlinked [6].
Proving that two batches are the same
Then two deliberately wrong creams were made — one with 25% less active content and one with 26% more — and tested against the reference [1]. Neither fell within the sameness criteria, which confirmed that the method could detect a real difference when one existed [1]. A separate cream made at the matching concentration was shown to be equivalent to the reference [1]. The authors note the potential for general use of the approach with other topical products [1].
That is the shape of a useful release test: it must pass a product against itself, and fail a product that has been changed on purpose. A test that passes everything tells you nothing.
Where an ingredient ends up inside the emulsion
An emulsion is also a place to park ingredients. In the itraconazole study, polarised light microscopy and differential scanning calorimetry were used to show that the material was fully dissolved in the O/W cream, rather than sitting as solid particles — and the fully solubilised cream performed differently from a simple physical mixture of the same base and the same material [5].
Another study carried essential oils inside ethanolic lipid vesicles, which were then spiked into an oil-in-water cream and compared with conventional creams made without vesicles [7]. The vesicles were characterised by vesicle size, polydispersity index, encapsulation efficiency and scanning electron microscopy, and the finished creams were evaluated for homogeneity, spreadability, viscosity, pH, in vitro antioxidant capacity and sun protection factor [7]. The vesicle-loaded creams showed notable in vitro antioxidant capacity compared with the non-vesicular versions, and sun protection factor values of 10.26 and 18.54 for the two oils [7].
Whether an added ingredient keeps working after it has been put into a cream is a fair question to ask. A survey of commercial cosmetic creams on the Thai market measured total phenolic contents of 0.46–47.92 mg GAE per 30 g of cream and antioxidant activities of 3.61–43.98 mg Trolox equivalent per 30 g, with a moderately positive correlation between the two (r = 0.6108) [4]. The authors frame the findings as showing how such effects could be maintained after products have been formulated [4].
Viscosity is part of the product, not a side effect
Texture is not only an engineering outcome; it is something the buyer judges directly. In four studies, participants tried two face creams — one high viscosity, one low viscosity — each at one of three odour levels: standard, half standard, or base with no added odour [8]. They rated liking of the product and its texture, and gave "just about right" evaluations of texture and visual appearance [8].
Both odour and texture affected the ratings, and there were interaction effects between them [8]. Adding odour generally increased global liking and texture liking, and in some cases changed the supposedly objective texture evaluations [8]. The studies were run in France and in China, and with the creams applied on the hands as in a store and on the face as at home; the effects varied by country and context [8].
What a brand can take from this
Decide the phase structure first, because everything else follows from it — including whether an ingredient is dissolved in the cream or merely mixed into it [5]. Expect a small number of ingredients, often the waxy and emollient ones, to control the texture, and expect their percentages to need deliberate optimisation rather than a single trial [6]. Agree a release test early and check that it can fail a cream you have changed on purpose, not only pass the one you like [1].
References
- Rath S, Kanfer I. A Validated IVRT Method to Assess Topical Creams Containing Metronidazole Using a Novel Approach — Pharmaceutics, 2020-02-03.
- Ali A, Akhtar N, Chowdhary F. Enhancement of human skin facial revitalization by moringa leaf extract cream — Postepy dermatologii i alergologii, 2014-04-22.
- Celik SBG, Dominici SR, Filby BW, Das AAK, Madden LA, Paunov VN. Fabrication of Human Keratinocyte Cell Clusters for Skin Graft Applications by Templating Water-in-Water Pickering Emulsions — Biomimetics (Basel, Switzerland), 2019-07-11.
- Mapoung S, Semmarath W, Arjsri P, Umsumarng S, Srisawad K, Thippraphan P, Yodkeeree S, Limtrakul Dejkriengkraikul P. Determination of Phenolic Content, Antioxidant Activity, and Tyrosinase Inhibitory Effects of Functional Cosmetic Creams Available on the Thailand Market — Plants (Basel, Switzerland), 2021-07-06.
- Kim H, Jung S, Yeo S, Kim D, Na YC, Yun G, Lee J. Characteristics of Skin Deposition of Itraconazole Solubilized in Cream Formulation — Pharmaceutics, 2019-04-22.
- Alves T, Arranca D, Martins A, Ribeiro H, Raposo S, Marto J. Complying with the Guideline for Quality and Equivalence for Topical Semisolid Products: The Case of Clotrimazole Cream — Pharmaceutics, 2021-04-14.
- Lohani A, Verma A, Verma A, Hema G, Pathak K. Topical Delivery of Geranium/Calendula Essential Oil-Entrapped Ethanolic Lipid Vesicular Cream to Combat Skin Aging — BioMed research international, 2021-09-11.
- Courrèges S, Aboulaasri R, Bhatara A, Bardel MH. Crossmodal Interactions Between Olfaction and Touch Affecting Well-Being and Perception of Cosmetic Creams — Frontiers in psychology, 2021-08-13.