Knowledge

How a Cream Stays Mixed: Emulsions, Emulsifiers and Film Behaviour

A cream or a lotion is two things that do not mix, made to behave as one. Oil and water are held together in a single pourable or scoopable product by an emulsifier — a material that sits at the boundary between the two and keeps the droplets apart. Model creams used in formulation research are described as oil-in-water emulsions, meaning oil droplets are dispersed through a continuous water phase [3].

Almost everything a brand cares about in a finished cream — how thick it is, how it feels, whether it is still the same product after six months in a warehouse — comes out of that structure. This article sets out what the published work says about how the structure is built and what controls it.

The parts of the formula

An emulsion has an oil phase, a water phase and an emulsifier. The oil phase is a choice, not a default. In one study of nano-emulsions built as a cosmetic matrix, the oils were miglyol, rapeseed oil and salmon oil, combined in proportions set by a mixture design [5]. The researchers reported that rapeseed oil and miglyol were the predominant parameters determining the characterisation of the emulsion — in other words, the choice of oil, and how much of each, drove the measured behaviour of the finished system [5].

The emulsifier is the second choice. In the same work, both tween 80 and soya lecithin were found to stabilise the formulations [5]. Two quite different emulsifiers can therefore both do the job; which one is used is a formulation decision rather than a fixed rule.

Beyond the structural ingredients sit the functional ones. Moisturisers are described in the literature as topical products designed to improve and maintain the skin barrier function and to help prevent dry skin [2]. The ingredients used for that purpose in cosmetic products include glycerol and fatty acids [1]. One cream studied was formulated with ingredients intended to mimic the skin's own natural moisturising systems [2].

HLB: matching the emulsifier to the oil

Emulsions are not equilibrium systems. The nano-emulsion study describes them explicitly as non-equilibrium systems whose characteristics and properties depend not only on composition but also on their method of preparation [5]. That is the single most useful sentence in the evidence for a brand owner: the same ingredient list, processed differently, is not the same product.

To decide which emulsifier suits which oil blend, formulators use HLB — the hydrophilic–lipophilic balance, a number describing how water-loving or oil-loving a material is. In the nano-emulsion work the RHLB (required HLB) was calculated for each formulation in order to achieve maximum stability [5]. Stability, in other words, is designed in at the arithmetic stage, before anything is mixed.

What gets measured

Because an emulsion is a physical structure rather than a simple solution, the tests that describe it are physical. The nano-emulsion study took measurements of size, electrophoretic mobility, conductivity, viscosity, turbidity, crystallisation and melting point [5]. The optimal formulation chosen was 56.5% rapeseed oil, 35.5% miglyol and 8% salmon oil, selected as the best candidate on the grounds of small droplet size, good turbidity and average HLB [5].

Those readings are a product specification in disguise. Droplet size and viscosity describe how the cream looks and spreads; melting and crystallisation behaviour describe what happens when it is shipped warm or stored cold.

The film the cream leaves behind

An emulsion stops being an emulsion as soon as it is spread. What remains is a film, and the properties of that film are measurable in their own right. Work on occluding barrier creams showed that a cream can form a film with a high resistance to the transport of water, and the authors developed an experimental method for measuring the specific resistance to water transport of films made of such creams [4]. They also built a quantitative model to predict water transport through the outer layer of the skin when it is covered by such a film [4].

What goes wrong

Three failure modes appear in the evidence, and none of them is separation of the oil and water.

Light. An active ingredient can degrade inside a perfectly stable cream. Model oil-in-water creams containing 1% EGCG, a catechin, were exposed to a solar simulator at an irradiance corresponding to natural sunlight; EGCG alone lost 76.9 ± 4.6% [3]. Adding co-antioxidants changed that sharply: vitamin C reduced the loss to 20.4 ± 2.7% and α-lipoic acid to 12.6 ± 1.6% [3]. Butylated hydroxytoluene had no effect, with an EGCG loss of 78.1 ± 4.6%, and vitamin E made the problem worse, raising photolysis to 84.5 ± 3.4% [3]. The lesson is that a stabiliser is specific to the ingredient it is protecting — one of the four tested actively harmed the formula it was added to [3].

Functional drift. The same study measured antioxidant power after irradiation and found the reduction in the formulation's antioxidant power (21.8%) was lower than the extent of chemical degradation (76.9%), which the authors attributed to the formation of photoproducts with antioxidant properties [3]. Chemical assay and functional assay can disagree, so both are worth running.

Contamination. Fifteen skin lightening creams sold in Trinidad and Tobago were analysed; fourteen contained mercury between 0.473 and 0.766 µg/g, and one contained 14,507.74 ± 490.75 µg/g [7]. All samples contained arsenic in the range 1.016 to 6.612 µg/g, exceeding the EU limit for cosmetics of 0 µg/g [7]. Heavy metals in a cream come from raw materials, not from the emulsion process, which is why raw-material testing sits upstream of mixing.

What a brand can take from this

Specify the oils, not just "oil" — the oil choice was the dominant factor in how the emulsion behaved [5]. Expect the emulsifier to be matched to that oil blend by an HLB calculation rather than chosen by habit [5]. Ask which physical readings will define the batch: droplet size, viscosity, turbidity and melting behaviour are all routinely measured [5]. If the formula contains a light-sensitive ingredient, ask which co-antioxidant was chosen and on what evidence, because the wrong one can accelerate loss rather than prevent it [3]. And remember that the processing method is part of the formula, not a detail added afterwards [5].

References

  1. Murphy B, Grimshaw S, Hoptroff M, Paterson S, Arnold D, Cawley A, Adams SE, Falciani F, Dadd T, Eccles R, Mitchell A, Lathrop WF, Marrero D, Yarova G, Villa A,. Alteration of barrier properties, stratum corneum ceramides and microbiome composition in response to lotion application on cosmetic dry skin — Scientific reports, 2022-03-26.
  2. Spada F, Barnes TM, Greive KA. Skin hydration is significantly increased by a cream formulated to mimic the skin's own natural moisturizing systems — Clinical, cosmetic and investigational dermatology, 2018-10-15.
  3. Scalia S, Marchetti N, Bianchi A. Comparative evaluation of different co-antioxidants on the photochemical- and functional-stability of epigallocatechin-3-gallate in topical creams exposed to simulated sunlight — Molecules (Basel, Switzerland), 2013-01-04.
  4. Sparr E, Millecamps D, Isoir M, Burnier V, Larsson Å, Cabane B. Controlling the hydration of the skin though the application of occluding barrier creams — Journal of the Royal Society, Interface, 2012-12-26.
  5. Kabri TH, Arab-Tehrany E, Belhaj N, Linder M. Physico-chemical characterization of nano-emulsions in cosmetic matrix enriched on omega-3 — Journal of nanobiotechnology, 2011-09-21.
  6. Sangoro O, Turner E, Simfukwe E, Miller JE, Moore SJ. A cluster-randomized controlled trial to assess the effectiveness of using 15% DEET topical repellent with long-lasting insecticidal nets (LLINs) compared to a placebo lotion on malaria transmission — Malaria journal, 2014-08-16.
  7. Mohammed T, Mohammed E, Bascombe S. The evaluation of total mercury and arsenic in skin bleaching creams commonly used in Trinidad and Tobago and their potential risk to the people of the Caribbean — Journal of public health research, 2017-10-09.
  8. Colvan L, Fleck T, Vega VL. Global periorbital skin rejuvenation by a topical eye cream containing low molecular weight heparan sulfate (LMW-HS) and a blend of naturally derived extracts — Journal of cosmetic dermatology, 2019-01-12.

All articles

Tell us what you want to make

Send us the product, the quantity and where you sell it.
Factory visits are welcome.

Contact us