The Pack Is Part of the Formula: What Packaging Does to a Cosmetic
A cosmetic is sold as two things at once: the formula and the thing it lives in. The research on cosmetic packaging suggests that is the wrong order. The pack decides how the product comes out, whether microorganisms get in, what chemistry can move from the wall into the contents, and what happens to the container after the last use.
Dispensing can change the product itself
The clearest evidence that packaging is not neutral comes from a study published in Pharmaceutical Research, which compared a single topical cream product sold in two packaging configurations: a tube and a pump [1]. The objective was to find out whether different dispensing processes can alter the physicochemical and structural attributes of a topical cream, and potentially alter its performance [1].
The researchers examined the cream dispensed from each configuration by optical microscopy, confocal Raman microscopy and cryo-scanning electron microscopy, and also evaluated the rheological behaviour of the products — that is, how the cream flows and deforms [1]. Even though the product inside each pack appeared to be the same in its structural attributes, differences appeared once it had been dispensed [1]. Visible globules were recognised in the sample that came out of the pump, and confocal Raman microscopy identified them as dimethicone globules [1].
Those globules mattered. The differences in rheological behaviour could be attributed to them, because products that were not dispensed through the pump demonstrated a similar rheological behaviour to each other [1]. The authors concluded that different methods of dispensing topical semisolid products can result in metamorphosis and structural changes [1]. The practical lesson for a brand is blunt: the act of pushing an emulsion through a pump mechanism can rearrange it. A cream qualified in a tube is not automatically the same cream in a pump.
Packaging as the microbial barrier
The second job of a pack is keeping the outside out. A study in AMB Express describes why this has become more urgent: doubts surrounding the potential adverse effects of antimicrobial preservatives have changed consumer demand, with increasing insistence on low-preservative and even preservative-free cosmetics [3]. When preservative load comes down, protection of the product against microbial contamination becomes focused on the packaging [3].
That shift produced a highly diverse array of packaging described as "protective", "overprotective" and "barrier" — but the paper notes that these designations are not normalised, and that choosing the right packaging for each cosmetic product remains essentially empirical, hazardous and time consuming [3]. In other words, the words on a supplier's datasheet have not meant anything measurable.
The work set out to fix that. A commission defined a complete and experimentally validated method to classify how well cosmetic packaging protects against microbial contamination [3]. On the basis of tests performed on over 800 packages of different origin and performance characteristics, the authors proposed a classification divided into six grades to differentiate protective efficiency [3]. They describe the work as a first step towards a regulatory text [3].
For a brand reducing preservatives, this is the missing vocabulary. A pack can be placed on a graded scale instead of being described with an adjective.
What moves out of the plastic
Protection runs the other way too. A study in Polymers investigated eleven plastic packaging materials covering five major polymer types — three PET, one HDPE, four LDPE, two PP and one SAN — using in vitro cell-based reporter-gene assays and non-targeted chemical analysis by gas chromatography coupled to mass spectrometry [4].
To mimic cosmetic contact, six simulants were used — acidic, alkaline and neutral water, 30% ethanol, glycerin and paraffin — in migration assays performed by filling the packaging with the simulant and holding it for one month at 50 °C [4]. The choice of simulant mattered enormously. Extraction of the chemicals of interest was low in the aqueous simulants, and no activity was recorded in those leachates [4]. Two substances described as non-intentionally added substances — 2,4-di-tert-butyl phenol and 7,9-di-tert-butyl-1-oxaspiro(4,5)deca-6,9-diene-2,8-dione — were present in all the polymers, principally in PP and PE, and in the highest quantity in the paraffin simulant [4].
The useful generalisation is about oil. Water-based contents pulled very little out of the plastics tested; oily and glycerin-rich contents pulled out more [4]. The authors concluded that glycerin and liquid paraffin are relevant and complementary simulants for assessing what a cosmetic plastic releases [4]. A rich balm or an oil in the same bottle as a toner is not the same test case.
Design, and what happens after
Packaging is also the brand's first argument. A review in SN Business & Economics reports that around 73% of purchasing decisions are made at the point of sale, and identifies colour, shape, images, material and package convenience as the important design elements in cosmetic branding [2]. The paper argues there is a lack of a holistic approach to combining those elements in line with the consumer's perspective [2].
Those same aesthetic choices have a cost at the end of life. A dataset published in Data in Brief examined approximately 270 kg of post-consumer cosmetics and personal hygiene primary plastic packaging collected through a retail take-back system in Denmark, covering 6,503 individual samples from 72 retail stores, analysed between March and May 2025 [5]. The work investigates how aesthetic elements and delivery mechanisms influence recyclability, and each sample was weighed both in its returned wet state and again after cleaning, to quantify residual product left inside [5]. The authors note that cosmetics packaging is increasingly targeted by regulatory frameworks emphasising design-for-recycling, take-back systems and producer responsibility, and that these products must appeal to consumers while also enabling safe delivery of the product during its intended use [5].
Material alternatives are being built. A study in Scientific Reports describes a fully biobased, biodegradable composite developed for cosmetic packaging, combining PHBV, polylactic acid, chitosan, acetyl tributyl citrate, plant essential oils and phycocyanin [6]. Characterisation showed a reduction in mechanical properties with the addition of the citrate, essential oil and phycocyanin, with tensile results within the typical behaviour for PP and PE, and working temperatures in the same range as PP and PE [6].
What a brand should take from this
Choose the pack while the formula is still being settled, not after. If a pump is on the table, the cream should be assessed as it comes out of the pump, because dispensing can change its structure and flow [1]. If the preservative system is light, the pack is doing the protecting, and it can now be graded rather than described [3]. If the formula is oily or high in glycerin, migration from the plastic deserves testing with simulants that match it [4]. And the shape, colour and dispensing mechanism that win at the shelf [2] are the same features that decide what happens when the empty container is returned [5].
References
- Mohammed YH, Namjoshi SN, Telaprolu KC, Jung N, Shewan HM, Stokes JR, Benson HAE, Grice JE, Raney SG, Rantou E, Windbergs M, Roberts MS. Impact of Different Packaging Configurations on A Topical Cream Product — Pharmaceutical research, 2024-09-30.
- Srivastava P, Ramakanth D, Akhila K, Gaikwad KK. Package design as a branding tool in the cosmetic industry: consumers' perception vs. reality — SN business & economics, 2022-05-21.
- Catovic C, Martin S, Desaint S, Borges C, Lesouhaitier H, Roullet F, Bresciani N, Jouault AM, Poulet V, Luc J, Joulia V, Jupin A, Masson C, Crozier A, Feuillole. Development of a standardized method to evaluate the protective efficiency of cosmetic packaging against microbial contamination — AMB Express, 2020-04-24.
- Bou-Maroun E, Dahbi L, Dujourdy L, Ferret PJ, Chagnon MC. Migration Studies and Endocrine Disrupting Activities: Chemical Safety of Cosmetic Plastic Packaging — Polymers, 2023-10-06.
- Moscatelli G, Logan HM, Ipsen LD, Bisgaard JS, Astrup JHH, de Souza RG, Eriksen MK, Damgaard A. Cosmetics and personal hygiene primary plastic packaging dataset: Characterization of post-consumer waste returned via take-back system in Denmark — Data in brief, 2025-11-23.
- Santos F, Rodrigues P, Vargas P, Massano A, Oliveira LM, Batista C, Cruz V, Mateus A, Mitchell GR, Sobral AJFN, Encarnação T. A novel fully biobased material composite for cosmetic packaging applications — Scientific reports, 2025-07-24.
- Simpson AHRW, Howie CR, Kinsella E, Hamilton DF, Conaghan PG, Hankey C, Simpson SA, Bell-Higgs A, Craig P, Clement ND, Keerie C, Kingsbury SR, Leeds AR, Ross HM. Correction to: Osteoarthritis Preoperative Package for care of Orthotics, Rehabilitation, Topical and oral agent Usage and Nutrition to Improve ouTcomes at a Year (OPPORTUNITY); a feasibility study protocol for a randomised controlled trial — Trials, 2020-04-20.