Knowledge

How Surfactants Clean Hair and Skin — And What Decides Harshness

A shampoo or a face wash is built around surfactants — molecules that let water carry away oil and dirt. Everything else in the bottle, the thickener, the fragrance, the preservative, sits around that core. Shampoos are primarily products aimed at cleansing the hair and scalp [7]. Getting the surfactant part right decides whether a product cleans well, feels mild, and holds its foam.

Cleaning is only half of what a surfactant does

Surfactants in skin cleansers interact with the skin in several ways [1]. Alongside the intended benefit of hygiene, they also extract skin components during cleansing and remain in the stratum corneum — the outermost layer of the skin — after rinsing [1]. Those side effects disrupt the structure of that layer and degrade its barrier properties [1].

This is the central design problem of any cleanser. The same property that lifts oil off a surface lets the surfactant interact with the surface itself. A formula is not simply "strong" or "mild"; mildness is something you engineer into the surfactant system.

What actually makes a cleanser harsh

The most useful finding for a brand owner is that harshness does not track the amount of surfactant on the label. One study looked at two commonly studied surfactants, sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) and dodecyl trimethylammonium bromide (C12TAB), and their effect on skin barrier properties [3]. Using skin conductivity, FT-IR of stratum corneum samples, and penetration of radiolabelled SDS, the researchers found that adding C12TAB lowered the ability of SDS to perturb the barrier [3].

Ultrafiltration experiments explained why: adding the second surfactant decreased the concentration of monomers and sub-micellar aggregates [3]. Monomers are single surfactant molecules floating free in the water, rather than bound up in the larger clusters called micelles. None of the measured skin properties — conductivity enhancement, lipid structure perturbation, or skin concentration of SDS — correlated with the total SDS concentration in the donor compartment [3]. All of them correlated well against the concentration of monomers and sub-micellar aggregates [3].

In other words, the free, small, unbound fraction does the damage. A formula can carry plenty of surfactant and still be gentle if that surfactant is held in large assemblies. This is why blending surfactants is a formulation decision, not a cost decision.

Building bigger structures on purpose

The commercial route to the same effect is described in a review of cleansing formulations [1]. The main approach to making a cleanser that both cleanses and respects the skin barrier is to minimise surfactant interaction with skin by altering the solution properties of the surfactant [1]. Hydrophobically modified polymers (HMPs) have been introduced to create skin-compatible cleansing systems [1]. In the presence of an HMP, surfactants assemble into larger, more stable structures [1]. Those structures are less likely to penetrate the skin, which results in a less aggressive cleanser and maintains the integrity of the skin barrier [1].

The review notes that recent applications of vibrational spectroscopy and two-photon microscopy in skin research have provided molecular-level information about how skin and surfactant interact [1]. That is the evidence base behind the structure-building approach.

pH: a real variable, with no agreed number

For hair, pH matters separately from surfactant choice. One study reviewed the literature on low-pH shampoos and measured the pH of 123 shampoos from international brands [2]. The values ranged from 3.5 to 9.0 [2]. Just over 38% of the 123 shampoos had a pH of 5.5 or below, and about 62% were above 5.5 [2].

The split differed sharply by product type [2]:

  • Of 26 anti-dandruff shampoos, 19.23% had a pH of 5.5 or below and 80.77% were above it [2].
  • Of 19 dermatological shampoos, 42.10% were at or below 5.5 [2].
  • Of 96 commercial or popular products, 34.37% were at or below 5.5 [2].
  • Of 15 professional salon products, 75% were at or below 5.5 [2].
  • Every children's shampoo tested was above 5.5, with a pH of 7.0 attributed to the "no-tear" concept [2].

The authors conclude that alkaline pH may increase the negative electrical charge of the hair fibre surface and therefore increase friction between fibres, which may lead to cuticle damage and fibre breakage [2]. They state it is a reality and not a myth that a lower shampoo pH may cause less frizzing, by generating less negative static electricity on the fibre surface [2]. They also note there is no standardised value for the final pH, that they believe the pH value should be revealed on the label, and that studies are still needed to establish the best range [2].

What gets measured on a finished shampoo

A study of six shampoo brands collected from the Riyadh market evaluated them against Saudi standard specifications for shampoos [7]. The tests used were organoleptic characterisation, pH measurement, percentage of solid content, rheological measurements, dirt dispersion level, foaming ability and foam stability, and surface tension [7]. All the shampoos had a good percentage of solids, excellent foam formation with stable foam, and a highly viscous nature [7]. All samples fell within the specified pH range and showed good wetting ability [7].

That list is a practical specification sheet. Foam volume and foam stability, viscosity, solids, surface tension, wetting and dirt dispersion are the properties a batch can be checked against, alongside pH.

Preservatives in the formula can also be measured. One method used a chromium-based metal organic framework as a sorbent for pipette tip micro-solid phase extraction to concentrate parabens from shampoo samples before spectrophotometric analysis [8]. The linear range for parabens was 1.0–200.0 μg/L, with detection limits of 0.24 µg/L for propyl paraben and 0.25 µg/L for methyl paraben, and reproducibility better than 5.78% RSD [8]. Analytical methods of this sensitivity exist for checking what is actually present in a finished shampoo [8].

What a brand can take from this

Three decisions do most of the work. First, the surfactant blend: harshness followed the free monomer and sub-micellar fraction, not the total surfactant level, and adding a second surfactant reduced that fraction [3]. Third, pH — a real variable for hair, with a measured industry range of 3.5 to 9.0 and no standardised target [2].

References

  1. Walters RM, Mao G, Gunn ET, Hornby S. Cleansing formulations that respect skin barrier integrity — Dermatology research and practice, 2012-08-13.
  2. Gavazzoni Dias MF, de Almeida AM, Cecato PM, Adriano AR, Pichler J. The Shampoo pH can Affect the Hair: Myth or Reality? — International journal of trichology, 2014-07-01.
  3. James-Smith MA, Hellner B, Annunziato N, Mitragotri S. Effect of surfactant mixtures on skin structure and barrier properties — Annals of biomedical engineering, 2010-11-10.
  4. Soleimani-Ahmadi M, Jaberhashemi SA, Zare M, Sanei-Dehkordi A. Prevalence of head lice infestation and pediculicidal effect of permethrine shampoo in primary school girls in a low-income area in southeast of Iran — BMC dermatology, 2017-07-24.
  5. Draelos ZD. Essentials of Hair Care often Neglected: Hair Cleansing — International journal of trichology, 2010-01-01.
  6. Cavello IA, Hours RA, Cavalitto SF. Bioprocessing of "Hair Waste" by Paecilomyces lilacinus as a Source of a Bleach-Stable, Alkaline, and Thermostable Keratinase with Potential Application as a Laundry Detergent Additive: Characterization and Wash Performance Analysis — Biotechnology research international, 2012-12-17.
  7. AlQuadeib BT, Eltahir EKD, Banafa RA, Al-Hadhairi LA. Pharmaceutical evaluation of different shampoo brands in local Saudi market — Saudi pharmaceutical journal : SPJ : the official publication of the Saudi Pharmaceutical Society, 2017-10-06.
  8. Kaykhaii M, Hashemi SH, Andarz F, Piri A, Sargazi G. Chromium-based metal organic framework for pipette tip micro-solid phase extraction: an effective approach for determination of methyl and propyl parabens in wastewater and shampoo samples — BMC chemistry, 2021-11-06.

All articles

Tell us what you want to make

Send us the product, the quantity and where you sell it.
Factory visits are welcome.

Contact us