Knowledge

What Gives a Gel Its Body: Thickeners, Viscosity and Flow

A gel is a liquid held in place. Most of what is in the jar is water, but it does not run off the hand, because a small amount of a thickening material forms a network through it. That network is what formulators call the gelling agent, and it decides almost everything a customer notices: how stiff the product is, whether it spreads or drags, how slowly it lets its contents go.

Published formulation work gives a useful picture of how that choice plays out, because researchers measure the things a brand owner can only feel. The most common measurement is viscosity — a number for how much a material resists flowing. In one study of topical gels, three gel versions of the same formula were compared, and their dynamic viscosity ranged from 812.21 ± 20.22 to 1222.76 ± 131.99 Pa.s [2]. Those gels also differed in pH, from 5.94 ± 0.03 to 7.53 ± 0.03, and each batch was additionally checked for homogeneity, meaning whether the gel looked and behaved the same throughout [2]. Content, viscosity, pH, homogeneity: that short list is roughly the routine a gel goes through before anyone judges it by hand.

Thickeners are not interchangeable

It is usually doing more than one job.

Poloxamers are a clear example. In a study of topical gels, poloxamers were used both as a solubiliser — something that helps a poorly soluble material dissolve — and as the gelling agent [4]. Two grades were compared. At 5%, poloxamer 407 and poloxamer 188 increased the solubility of the plant material they carried by 2.86 and 2.06 folds; at 10%, by 2.81 and 2.59 folds [4]. The two grades also behaved differently once loaded: micelle size in the poloxamer 188 formulation increased in the presence of the added material, while the poloxamer 407 formulation showed no change [4].

The same study shows how viscosity feeds back into performance. Release rates fell as the poloxamer 188 concentration rose, and the authors attributed that to the increase in viscosity [4]. More thickener gave a firmer gel and a slower release. That trade-off is worth holding on to: a brand asking for a noticeably thicker gel is also, usually, asking for a slower one.

Cellulose-type thickeners are used differently. In a study of nanoemulsions and lipid-based carriers intended for skin, hydroxyethylcellulose was added specifically to produce hydrogel-thickened versions, with the stated aim of improving the viscosity and skin adherence of the formulations [8]. The resulting hydrogels showed pseudoplastic behaviour with bioadhesive characteristics [8]. Pseudoplastic means the material thins while it is being sheared — pumped, squeezed, or rubbed out — and thickens again when the force stops. That is the flow behaviour most people expect from a gel: firm in the tube, easy under the fingers.

What the network is made of

Many cosmetic gels lean on polysaccharides — long sugar chains from plant or other natural sources. Their composition is not uniform, and it is not fixed by the species alone. An analysis of Aloe vera tissues found that skin juice contained 2.4 times the level of polysaccharides found in gel juice from the same plant [1]. The chemistry differed too: after separation, neutral polysaccharides accounted for 58.1% of the recovered preparation from gel juice and 78.5% from skin juice, while flower polysaccharides were largely weakly acidic, at 84.2% [1]. Glucose and galactose were the most abundant single sugars in the neutral fractions from gel juice and skin juice respectively, and the acidic fractions contained glucuronic acid, galactose, glucose, mannose and xylose in variable proportions [1].

Another family of gelling materials sets by temperature rather than by water-binding. Gelatins prepared from goat skin had gelling temperatures of 23.02°C to 24.16°C and melting temperatures of 33.07°C to 34.51°C [6]. Gel strength rose as the alkaline pretreatment concentration and time increased, and one condition produced a gel strength of 222.42 g, higher than the bovine gelatin used for comparison at 199.15 g [6]. Longer pretreatment also changed the colour, lowering the L* value and raising the b* value [6]. Here the processing conditions, not just the source, set the final body of the gel — and they also moved the colour, which is a cosmetic concern as much as a technical one.

Blending two thickeners

Mixing polymers changes the result in ways that are hard to predict from either one alone. The starch improved the viscous behaviour of the solutions, with the loss modulus exceeding the storage modulus [5]. As starch concentration rose, tensile strength, elongation at break and elastic modulus of the resulting films all increased, while water solubility fell [5]. Surface smoothness and internal structure improved with starch incorporation [5]. The authors identified 6% starch as the most promising level on physical performance [5] — not the highest dose, but the best-balanced one. That is the usual shape of a thickener optimisation: performance improves to a point and then the formula is simply stiffer, not better.

The gel as a carrier

A gel base also governs how quickly its contents leave. In a comparison of caffeine delivery systems, the nanocarrier version showed a sustained release profile over 24 hours relative to caffeine loaded in a conventional gel [3]. In the asiatic acid work, gels built around carrier systems gave markedly higher percentage penetration into a synthetic membrane at 8 hours than the non-carrier gels, which ranged from 0.73 ± 0.44 to 3.13 ± 0.46% [2]. In the dillapiole study, the hydrogel-thickened systems exhibited a controlled release profile and showed low irritant potential in a chorioallantoic membrane test [8].

What a brand can take from this

Pick the thickener before arguing about the texture. Ask for viscosity, pH and homogeneity to be recorded on every batch, as formulation studies do [2], so "the same as last time" has a number behind it. Expect a concentration ladder rather than a single guess, because blends tend to have an optimum in the middle of the range rather than at the top [5].

References

  1. Nejatzadeh-Barandozi F, Enferadi ST. FT-IR study of the polysaccharides isolated from the skin juice, gel juice, and flower of Aloe vera tissues affected by fertilizer treatment — Organic and medicinal chemistry letters, 2012-10-24.
  2. Opatha SAT, Titapiwatanakun V, Boonpisutiinant K, Chutoprapat R. Preparation, Characterization and Permeation Study of Topical Gel Loaded with Transfersomes Containing Asiatic Acid — Molecules (Basel, Switzerland), 2022-07-29.
  3. Elsheikh MA, Gaafar PME, Khattab MA, A Helwah MK, Noureldin MH, Abbas H. Dual-effects of caffeinated hyalurosomes as a nano-cosmeceutical gel counteracting UV-induced skin ageing — International journal of pharmaceutics: X, 2023-02-10.
  4. An SH, Ban E, Chung IY, Cho YH, Kim A. Antimicrobial Activities of Propolis in Poloxamer Based Topical Gels — Pharmaceutics, 2021-11-26.
  5. Alias SA, Mhd Sarbon N. Rheological, physical, and mechanical properties of chicken skin gelatin films incorporated with potato starch — NPJ science of food, 2019-12-04.
  6. Mad-Ali S, Benjakul S, Prodpran T, Maqsood S. Characteristics and Gel Properties of Gelatin from Goat Skin as Influenced by Alkaline-pretreatment Conditions — Asian-Australasian Journal of Animal Sciences, 2015-12-08.
  7. Kelić M, Kilić D, Kelić K, Šutej I, Par M, Peroš K, Tarle Z. The Fluoride Ion Release from Ion-Releasing Dental Materials after Surface Loading by Topical Treatment with Sodium Fluoride Gel — Journal of functional biomaterials, 2023-02-13.
  8. Carneiro SB, Kreutz T, Limberger RP, Teixeira HF, da Veiga Júnior VF, Koester LS. Piper aduncum Essential Oil Rich in Dillapiole: Development of Hydrogel-Thickened Nanoemulsion and Nanostructured Lipid Carrier Intended for Skin Delivery — Pharmaceutics, 2022-11-19.

All articles

Tell us what you want to make

Send us the product, the quantity and where you sell it.
Factory visits are welcome.

Contact us